Best Auto Insurance for Luxury and Exotic Vehicles in 2025 (Top 10 Companies)

Geico, State Farm, and Progressive have the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles, with starting rates from $165 monthly. Geico combines 25% bundling savings with digital quote technology. State Farm’s massive agent network ensures authentic OEM part sourcing, while Progressive protects collector cars with specialized agreed-value coverage.

These providers understand that the demand for exotic vehicles requires more than standard protection. Many people dream of owning a beautiful car.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Auto Insurance for Luxury and Exotic Vehicles

Aside from the expensive price tag and hefty maintenance fee, most think very little about the insurance coverage when they buy a new car with a high value.

This article will tell you everything you need to know about purchasing an exotic car insurance policy for your prized vehicle. Get the best luxury auto insurance quotes today with our quote comparison tool.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#1 – Geico: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Bundled Rate Advantages: Competitive exotic car insurance rates with bundling discounts for high-end vehicles.
• Digital Quote Innovation: Discover everything you need to know about Geico and its digital platform that delivers instant luxury car insurance quotes.
• Specialized Claims Expertise: Round-the-clock claims specialists trained in the best car insurance for luxury cars and exotic vehicles.

Cons

• Limited Collector Options: High-end auto policies lack customization for rare collector automobiles.
• Aftermarket Exclusions: Modification coverage excludes certain aftermarket upgrades on exotic models.

#2 – State Farm: Best for Reliable Plan

Pros

• Personal Agent Access: Extensive agent network personalizes luxury auto insurance consultations.
• Authentic Parts Guarantee: As mentioned in our State Farm insurance review, its superior replacement part sourcing ensures authentic exotic car repairs.
• Bundle Discount Benefits: Multi-policy savings enhance the value of auto insurance plans for exotic cars.

Cons

• Slower Quote Process: The traditional quote process moves more slowly than digital-first luxury car insurance companies.
• Performance Use Restrictions: Track-day exclusions limit coverage for performance-driven exotic owners.

#3 – Progressive: Best for Online Aid

Pros

• Advanced Quote Technology: Cutting-edge technology simplifies the quote process for car insurance for exotic cars.
• Vehicle Value Protection: Agreed-value options protect the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles.
• Rate Optimization Tools: Learn everything you need to know about Progressive insurance, as its price comparison tools help optimize exotic car insurance rates.

Cons

• Higher Deductible Requirements: Premium deductible levels challenge budget-conscious luxury owners.
• Limited Rare Car Focus: Ultra-rare vehicles receive less specialized attention than mainstream exotics.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#4 – USAA: Best for Military Families

Pros

• Military-Only Advantages: Military-exclusive benefits elevate the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles (Read More: USAA insurance review).
• Claims Service Excellence: Renowned claims satisfaction sets the standard for high-end auto policies.
• Free Roadside Benefits: Complimentary roadside assistance supports luxury car insurance members.

Cons

• Civilian Access Denied: Membership restrictions exclude civilian exotic vehicle enthusiasts.
• Fewer Local Offices: Limited physical locations hinder face-to-face consultations for specialized coverage.

#5 – Allstate: Best for Accident Forgiveness

Pros

• Rate Preservation Feature: Forgiveness benefit preserves rates for luxury auto insurance policyholders. Learn more about this feature in our Allstate auto insurance review.
• Customized Coverage Solutions: Tailored options create superior auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles.
• Original Parts Promise: OEM parts guarantee maintains authenticity for luxury car insurance claims.

Cons

• Higher Premium Costs: Premium pricing exceeds budget-friendly exotic car insurance alternatives.
• Complicated Policy Structure: Policy complexity overwhelms inexperienced high-end car owners.

#6 – Amica: Best for Customer Service

Pros

• Service Excellence Recognition: Award-winning service excels in luxury car insurance claims handling.
• Loyalty Reward System: As highlighted in our Amica insurance review, its dividend program rewards devoted exotic vehicle insurance customers.
• Collector Car Flexibility: Collector-friendly policies accommodate unique high-end auto insurance needs.

Cons

• Geographic Limitations: Regional availability limits access to competitive exotic car insurance rates.
• Fewer Discount Offerings: Discount programs underperform versus mainstream insurance giants.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#7 – Farmers: Best for Customizable Policies

Pros

• Adaptable Coverage Plans: Flexible coverage designs are perfect for the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles.
• Luxury Insurance Specialists: See everything you need to know about Farmers Insurance and its expert agents that specialize in luxury auto insurance complexities.
• Classic Vehicle Knowledge: Vintage expertise translates to classic, exotic car protection.

Cons

• Premium Pricing Structure: Above-market costs impact the competitiveness of luxury car insurance quotes.
• Tech Platform Weaknesses: Digital capabilities lag behind tech-savvy insurance providers.

#8 – Nationwide: Best for Comprehensive Coverage

Pros

• Complete Protection Packages: All-inclusive packages fortify the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles.
• Elite Service Reputation: Premium service reputation benefits high-end vehicle insurance clients. Learn more about its ratings in our Nationwide insurance review.
• Extended Accessory Coverage: Accessory coverage extends beyond fundamental luxury car insurance limits.

Cons

• Value Coverage Constraints: Agreed-value restrictions disappoint exotic car insurance seekers.
• Limited Expert Availability: The specialist shortage affects the availability of luxury auto insurance expertise.

#9 – Liberty Mutual: Best for New-Car Replacement

Pros

• Vehicle Replacement Benefit: As highlighted in our Liberty Mutual insurance review, its new-car replacement feature enhances luxury car insurance value.
• Certified Repair Network: An authorized repair network that ensures quality exotic vehicle restoration.
• Teacher Discount Program: Educator incentives reduce costs for academic luxury auto owners.

Cons

• Extended Processing Times: The lengthy approval process delays the confirmation of exotic car insurance rates.
• Costly Deductible Levels: Elevated deductibles increase out-of-pocket luxury vehicle expenses.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#10 – Travelers: Best for Hybrid Vehicles

Pros

• Electric Luxury Expertise: Electric vehicle proficiency covers emerging luxury hybrid exotics (Read More: Travelers Auto Insurance).
• Premium Protection Plans: Elite protection maximizes the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles.
• Manufacturer Parts Commitment: Factory parts promise to preserve high-end auto policy integrity.

Cons

• Online Interface Issues: Web platform limitations frustrate complex luxury car insurance quotes.
• Minimal Savings Opportunities: Discount scarcity reduces the optimization potential of exotic car insurance rates.

Definition of Luxury and Exotic Vehicles

The definition of luxury and exotic can differ depending on each consumer’s standards. But in general, luxury cars are vehicles that are designed to stand out from the crowd and are made with higher-quality materials.

Although not every line they make is qualified as luxurious, these brands have earned a reputation for consistently producing high-quality, tasteful-looking automobiles with advanced technology features and gadgets.

The most common brands you see on an everyday basis are Mercedes-Benz, Infiniti, BMW, Audi, Acura, Lexus, Jaguar, and Cadillac.

There are even higher-end luxury ones such as Bentley, Rolls-Royce, and the ultra-top line of Mercedes-Benz. But what sets exotic autos apart from our everyday cars? These rare collectible items are:

• Super high performance and require a lot of experience to handle them properly.
• They usually cost more than $100,000 and up. Unique, limited edition, new exotic ones can cost as much as $500,000. Antique collectors’ exotic ones can even run into millions of dollars.
• They require specific tools to repair and maintain. Even a simple oil change and regular maintenance job without the proper tools and a designated auto body shop will void the warranty.
• Repairs are guaranteed to be expensive because only genuine parts from the original manufacturer will be used for replacements. Using non-genuine parts will not only void the warranty but also depreciate the value and performance.

As you have probably seen from many action films, these exotic beauties come from Porsche, McLaren, Lamborghini, Ferrari, Aston Martin, and Maserati brands. If you own multiple luxury or exotic vehicles, read our cheap auto insurance for multiple vehicles.

Average Luxury and Exotic Car Insurance Costs

Finding yearly insurance estimates for luxury and exotic vehicles can be challenging. These vehicles are so rare and uniquely priced that most consumer-focused surveys don’t include them in standard comparisons.

Instead, they are often treated as statistical outliers, making their inclusion in national averages inconsistent or not useful to the everyday driver. That’s why this breakdown is so valuable. It presents luxury car insurance rates across major insurers, both for minimum coverage and full coverage:

Exotic Vehicle Auto Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Coverage Level

These auto insurance rates from the table above are typically based on the profile of a common policyholder. A single, 40-year-old male with good credit and a clean driving record who travels 12 miles to work.

This standard profile includes an average plan limit of $100,000 in injury liability for one person, $300,000 for all injuries, $50,000 for property damage in an accident, and a $500 deductible on both collision and comprehensive coverage.

Why do luxury and exotic car insurance costs so much? In general, you can expect your premium rate to reflect the price of your auto. But you may ask why the discrepancy is so big. This is because:

• Pricy vehicles always cost more to fix as their parts are costlier.
• Luxury and exotic automobiles always require unique, original parts for replacement. The high-end automobiles are always imported from foreign countries. This makes it even harder to find the certified replacements and requires more money to ship these heavy parts to the United States.
• They require special tools to work on, and the technicians need extra training for the specificity of the jobs. This specialist charges much more than the average auto body shop technician. On top of that, these experts are only available in certain cities.
• Unlike economic ones, these high-end automobiles do not depreciate in market price. If anything, limited editions made for the anniversary celebration of these high-end manufacturers can increase in value over the years. If they are totaled or damaged, the price of replacing or fixing them is outrageously pricey.
• These high-performance automobiles tend to attract the young crowd of consumers who have a liking towards speed and risky driving habits. As a result, owners tend to be labeled as “high-risk drivers.”

If you’re in the market for a luxury or exotic car, knowing these insurance for expensive cars upfront can help you plan your budget and choose a provider that offers both premium service and competitive pricing.

Read More: The 17 Best Tips to Pay Less for Car Insurance

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Problems With Ultra-Exotic Vehicles

You may wonder why ultra-exotic automobiles such as Ferraris and Lamborghinis are excluded from the survey. This is because there are very few companies in the United States that can provide protection for these two brands. Not only that, but they are very selective about which model they will protect, and the requirements needed to comply are extremely strict.

According to a survey conducted by Quadrant Information Services, the starting cost of an annual Lamborghini protection plan is roughly between $5,000 and $20,000. Compared to the $3,000 to $5,000 cost of more common luxury autos, these high-end racecars can be a nightmare to insure.

You may think that the premium is so outrageous because of the value. That is only 1 reason. These providers charge such a hefty fee because:

• They consider these exotic automobiles a sign that the driver follows a certain dangerous lifestyle that includes driving at a high speed and engaging in risky driving behavior.
• Sports cars are costlier to insure because they require a professional to handle such a powerful vehicle. Driving by someone who has limited driving experience is considered a significant risk as they are much more likely to be involved in an accident that can lead to serious injury and damage to the auto. In the worst case, death can result from inexperienced drivers.
• Most owners want full coverage on their prized possessions and do not mind the extra cost as long as they are protected in the worst-case scenario.
• Many of the owners are young and within that “high-risk driver” range.

These high-end racecars are often targets of vandalism and theft activities just because they attract so much attention. So, you can see why the best car insurance companies see a $400,000 car and a $30,000 sedan so differently.

Value Determination With Insurance for Luxury Cars

When it comes to purchasing a protection plan, you should understand these 3 terms: agreed-value, actual cash value, and replacement cost. They dictate how much your provider will reimburse you for the damage and/or total cost.

• Agreed-Value: This is the price agreed upon by both the provider and the plan holder concerning the reimbursement cost in the event of major damage, total loss, or theft incident.
• Actual Cash Value: This is the amount of money the company owes you from damage, total loss, or theft. This value is set upon the current market value of your car minus the depreciation cost.
• Replacement Cost: This is similar to agreed-value, but it only applies to automobiles that have been owned for less than 3 years. This is the amount of money the carrier owes the owner in the event of a total loss or theft incident. In this case, the depreciation cost cannot be applied to the reimbursement cost.

What we learned from analyzing 815 insurance companies? When you are shopping for a luxury/exotic automobile policy, you must inquire whether the company applies the agreed-value or replacement cost value. If not, you can run into a problem when you find out that they will only honor the actual cash value system and reimburse you for their own maximum amount under their policies.

Problems With Normal Coverage Carriers for Exotic Car Insurance

Even though common automobile companies do underwrite policies for high-end autos, there are some serious drawbacks to their services.

Standard insurers often avoid agreed-value policies or charge high premiums for them. They cap payouts, label exotic cars as high-risk, and may raise rates on your daily car. Repairs must go through approved shops, risking warranty loss—otherwise, you’ll pay out-of-pocket beyond their limited reimbursement.

Read More: The Worst States for Filing an Auto Insurance Claim

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Specialty Insurance for Exotic Cars

Specialty protection is required to cover unique automobiles completely, which regular insurers would not usually cover. Even if the regular companies accept your application, they will only offer the maximum value they insure. What this means is that if you spent $250,000 on your luxury car, your insurer may not value your protection plan to that level.

If this is the case, if you total your autos, you will have to pay the difference between your maximum payout and the actual value. If you wonder whether an exotic car insurance policy is necessary, ask yourself these questions:

1. Is your auto worth more than where it is parked? If you park your $250,000 racecar at a location that only covers the $100,000 damage limit. If it is totaled at the location, you will only receive $100,000 for your loss.
2. Is it a one-of-a-kind, unique, and/or high-end racecar? These autos are often not accepted by the regular insurers. Your best bet is to go with a specialty provider.
3. Do you need a gap option to pay the difference between the maximum payout and the actual value of your car?

Just like getting a regular auto plan, all factors are taken into consideration when these exotic car insurance companies quote your premium:

• Brand and age of the auto
• Monthly/annual mileage and driving frequency
• Age of the driver and additional drivers on the policy
• Whether this is your primary or secondary transportation
• Exterior and interior condition, including any customizations

Because your car may have certain customization work added, these companies are very likely to request photographs and proof of these added accessories to document its actual worth and underwrite a plan for your needs.

Read More: Top 7 Ways You’re Wasting Money On Your Car (Right Now)

Why Specialized Auto Coverage is the Best Insurance for Exotic Cars

When you compare car insurance companies, specialized luxury cars insurance companies are a better choice.

Specialty insurers provide agreed-value coverage, rather than depreciated payments, so they are perfect for collectible vehicles. They know the market, provide choice repair, and cover damage related to an event.

More expensive, yes, but they come with benefits such as worldwide rental protection, roadside assistance, and even counseling following carjackings—along with a touch of prestige thrown in.

Limitations of Specialty Coverage Companies for Exotic Car Insurance

It may sound like a must for any driver who owns a luxury or exotic automobile, but the best insurance for luxury cars have their drawbacks as well:

Limitations of Specialty Exotic Car Insurance Providers

These limitations make specialty exotic car insurance challenging for younger drivers, those with imperfect records, or owners of modified vehicles.

Review these requirements carefully and make sure you know what to do when you’re denied insurance coverage, as violating policy terms can result in denied claims or canceled coverage entirely.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap insurance rates.

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Types of Exotic Car Insurance Coverage

Do you actually need a special luxury car policy, or will any plain one work? Luxury cars are different than economic ones. They cost more to make and maintain. Consequently, it makes sense that they cost a lot more to insure as well. Having said that, protection is the same no matter what type of vehicle you own.

When you bundle, you don’t have to pick 😉 #NFLDraft pic.twitter.com/LL0aBcY0Dm

— GEICO (@GEICO) April 27, 2023

• Liability Coverage: Although you always have the option to purchase your state’s minimum liability protection, you should know that this amount will most likely not be enough to cover the cost of any repair on your auto. When you purchase liability insurance, you should always consider the worst possible scenario and how much money is needed for the situation.
• Collision Coverage: Although you may have already decided that you will end up paying for most of the repair out of pocket, you should always purchase collision insurance in case your vehicle is totaled severely and needs to be replaced or repaired. Collision insurance is crucial because it is the only insurance that will cover the cost of repair and replacement of your automobile.
• Comprehensive Policy: Although comprehensive auto insurance is not a must-have for some drivers, it is definitely a must-have for luxury and exotic car owners. Exotic ones are only more likely to be stolen. Although this can increase your premium, it is definitely worth your money just in case it gets stolen or damaged.

The only difference you are going to see is the overall cost of the plan. The reason is that insurers have to pay more to repair or replace it if you happen to be in an accident. You most probably want to have a high level of protection that the insurer will cover.

Tips on Lowering Your Exotic Car Insurance Costs

Top auto insurance companies grant high discounts to luxury car owners. This comparison identifies possible savings through anti-theft devices, policy bundling, loyalty programs, new car sales, and good driving habits.

Auto Insurance Discounts From the Top Providers for Luxury and Exotic Vehicles

Although each provider has their own algorithm in calculating their applicants’ risk factors, most of them usually base their premiums on characteristics that suggest that you are a responsible driver and a trustworthy customer. Now for the less obvious tips to lower your premium cost:

Tips to Lower Exotic Car Insurance Premiums

Having a good credit history, maintaining a clean driving record with minimal accidents and traffic violations, and keeping your payments on time can all greatly help lower your premium rate, and these are all car insurance discounts you can’t miss.

Getting the Best Insurance for High-End Cars

Geico, State Farm, and Progressive are the leaders when it comes to luxury and exotic automobile insurance. Geico excels with 25% bundling discounts and lightning-fast digital quotes. State Farm provides genuine OEM parts via its extensive network of agents, while Progressive has agreed to value coverage that is perfect for covering collectible automobiles.

To find out if you can get cheaper auto insurance rates, enter your ZIP code into our free quote tool to instantly compare prices from various companies near you.