Best Auto Insurance for Teslas in 2025

Best for Teslas: Travelers

1,734 reviews

Compare Rates →

4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Teslas

$193/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A++

Complaint Level

Med

Pros & Cons

• Largest U.S. Insurer
• Nationwide Coverage
• Broad Insurance Options
• Below-Average Rates

• IntelliDrive Rate Increase
• Below-Average Reviews
• Limited Rideshare Availability

» Travelers Auto Insurance Review

1,734 reviews

Compare Rates →

2nd Best for Teslas: Progressive

13,285 reviews

Compare Rates →

4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Teslas

$208/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

Med

Pros & Cons

• Snapshot savings for safe drivers
• User-friendly mobile app
• Free accident forgiveness
• Flexible “Name Your Price” option

• Below-average customer satisfaction
• Slow claim payouts reported
• Limited availabilty of local agents

» Progressive Auto Insurance Review

13,285 reviews

Compare Rates →

3rd Best for Teslas: State Farm

18,157 reviews

Compare Rates →

4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Teslas

$190/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A++

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Competitive rates
• Flexible coverage
• Multiple discounts

• High-risk driver costs
• Limited digital tools

» State Farm Auto Insurance Review

18,157 reviews

Compare Rates →

The best auto insurance for Teslas comes from Travelers, Progressive, and State Farm. Travelers is the top pick overall, with full coverage available starting at under $200 per month, making it the cheapest car insurance option for Tesla owners.

Company	Rank	EV Discount	A.M. Best	Best For	Jump to Pros/Cons
	#1	9%	A++	EV Coverage	Travelers
	#2	8%	A+	Online Tools	Progressive
	#3	10%	A++	Affordable Rates	State Farm
	#4	14%	A+	High-Tech Features	Allstate
	#5	11%	A+	Tesla Discounts	Nationwide
	#6	12%	A	Custom Equipment	Farmers
	#7	16%	A++	Low Mileage Plans	Geico
	#8	11%	A	Roadside Help	Liberty Mutual
	#9	17%	A	Safe Driving	American Family
	#10	15%	A+	Repair Access	Erie

Progressive stands out with its easy-to-use tools and discounts, while State Farm provides solid rates and excellent customer service.

Tesla drivers are rewarded with special insurance features such as battery protection, autonomous driving coverage, and reduced rates for utilizing advanced safety features.

Companies With The Best Auto Insurance Rates for Teslas

Tesla insurance premiums differ by carrier. Travelers and Erie have cheap minimum coverage, and Liberty Mutual is more expensive. This table compares the Tesla insurance cost per month for minimum and full coverage.

Insurance Company	Minimum Coverage	Full Coverage
	$132	$261
	$94	$211
	$85	$195
	$120	$242
	$92	$205
	$139	$277
	$101	$219
	$98	$208
	$89	$190
	$86	$193

Full coverage shields your Tesla from theft, weather, and accidents, while minimum coverage insures only liability. State Farm and Travelers provide good full coverage for less than $200 a month, perfect for owners who want to save money.

Ensure that your policy limits cover the increased cost of replacement. Teslas are notoriously expensive to fix, and many insurers will total these vehicles rather than pay for repairs. Consider new car replacement or custom parts coverage to protect your investment.

Learn More: What to Do When You’re Denied Insurance Coverage

These companies provide the best balance of value and tailored policies for Tesla drivers. Get fast and cheap auto insurance coverage today with our quote comparison tool.

#1 – Travelers: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• EV-Specific Protections: Travelers offers specialized Tesla auto insurance that includes home charger and battery coverage.
• Bundling Savings: Tesla drivers can save up to 13% on insurance by bundling with Travelers’ home policies.
• Reliable Insurer: Travelers’ A++ rating reflects solid financial backing for Tesla insurance claims. Explore more ratings in our Travelers auto insurance review.

Cons

• Higher Urban Premiums: Tesla insurance rates through Travelers may rise significantly in big cities.
• Limited Tech Features: App and digital tools for managing insurance policies are basic compared to other Tesla car insurance companies.

#2 – Progressive: Best for Online Tools

Pros

• Strong Digital Experience: Progressive makes managing Tesla car insurance easy with user-friendly online tools that allow drivers to pick coverage based on budget.
• Usage-Based Discounts: Tesla drivers using Progressive’s Snapshot UBI can earn discounts by driving safely (Learn More: Everything You Need to Know About Progressive Insurance).
• Optional Upgrade Coverage: Add-ons like gap insurance and coverage for EV upgrades make Progressive the best auto insurance for Tesla Model 3.

Cons

• Lower Bundling Incentive: Progressive only offers a 10% discount for bundling Tesla auto insurance with other policies.
• Average Claims Ratings: Other Tesla insurance companies have higher satisfaction ratings, including State Farm.

#3 – State Farm: Best for Affordable Rates

Pros

• Cheap Full Coverage: State Farm has the best auto insurance rates for Teslas that need full coverage, starting at just $190 per month.
• Agent Network Support: Personalized service from local agents helps manage Tesla insurance needs.
• Strong Financial Rating: A++ rating means dependable coverage for Tesla car insurance policies.

Cons

• State Limitations: State Farm does not write new policies in RI or MA, and drivers in FL and CA may experience rate hikes. Learn more in our State Farm auto insurance review.
• Fewer Online Tools: State Farm doesn’t have some Tesla-friendly online options compared to more tech-oriented insurers.

#4 – Allstate: Best for High-Tech Features

Pros

• Tech-Focused Solutions: If you’re a Tesla driver who values digital tools and app-based convenience, our Allstate auto insurance review highlights this insurer as a strong option for tech-forward coverage.
• Smart Driving Rewards: Teslas with Allstate Drivewise can qualify for lower rates by tracking safe driving behavior.
• Top-Tier Bundling: Allstate car insurance for Teslas is eligible for bundling discounts up to 25%, which can translate to huge savings.

Cons

• Expensive for New Drivers: New Tesla drivers might pay more than with other companies.
• Slower Claim Processing: Some Tesla owners complain of delays in Allstate’s claim approval process.

#5 – Nationwide: Best for Tesla Discounts

Pros

• Exclusive Tesla Savings: Nationwide offers discounts for Teslas with advanced driver-assist features, making it the best auto insurance for Tesla Model Y.
• Solid Bundling Value: Tesla insurance costs drop with up to 20% savings on multi-policy bundles.
• Safe Driving Incentives: Tesla owners using Nationwide’s SmartRide UBI program may receive personalized discounts based on good driving habits.

Cons

• Repair Access Limitations: Tesla repairs under Nationwide will be more difficult to locate in rural areas.
• Not All Drivers Qualify: Some Tesla drivers may not earn the full SmartRide benefits due to driving patterns. Learn what impacts rates in our Nationwide auto insurance review.

#6 – Farmers: Best for Custom Equipment Coverage

Pros

• Coverage for Add-Ons: Our Farmers auto insurance review emphasizes the added advantage for Tesla owners with custom technology or modifications, providing specialized equipment protection.
• OEM Repair Assurance: Farmers repairs on Teslas include original manufacturer parts for better quality.
• Bundling Opportunities: By combining your Tesla insurance with a home or renters policy, you may be able to save up to 20%..

Cons

• Higher Rates in Some Areas: Farmers’ Tesla insurance prices can be elevated in certain states.
• Basic App Functionality: Limited tech integration for Tesla users wanting advanced digital tools.

#7 – Geico: Best for Low Mileage Plans

Pros

• Low-Mileage Perks: Tesla drivers who drive less can earn discounts through Geico’s low-mileage discounts.
• Strong Discount Packages: Up to 25% bundling savings make Geico cost-effective for Tesla insurance.
• EV Roadside Support: Offers Tesla-specific roadside services, including battery assistance and flat tire assistance.

Cons

• Few Tesla-Focused Add-Ons: Everything you need to know about Geico indicates that extras such as wall chargers may not be covered for Teslas.
• Minimal Agent Interaction: Tesla owners may miss personalized service due to Geico’s digital-first approach.

#8 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Roadside Help

Pros

• Tesla Roadside Coverage: Liberty Mutual provides specialized roadside help for Tesla breakdowns and battery issues.
• Top Bundling Discount: Tesla insurance customers can save up to 25% by combining policies.
• Parts & Tech Protection: Covers Tesla-specific features like glass panels and driver-assist sensors.

Cons

• Higher Urban Costs: Our Liberty Mutual insurance review points out that Tesla insurance premiums may be higher in urban areas than in other areas.
• App Limitations: Tesla drivers may find Liberty Mutual’s app lacks the advanced features of its competitors.

#9 – American Family: Best for Safe Driving Programs

Pros

• Safe Driver Incentives: Tesla drivers enrolled in the KnowYourDrive UBI program can qualify for premium discounts.
• Generous Bundling Offer: Tesla drivers receive up to 25% off when they bundle with other policies.
• Coverage for EV Systems: Optional protection extends to Tesla’s software and in-cabin tech systems.

Cons

• Shop Availability Issues: Some areas lack approved repair centers for Tesla insurance claims. Find out more in our American Family vs. Travelers review
• Less Transparent Claims: Tesla policyholders sometimes experience vague updates during claims.

#10 – Erie Insurance: Best for Repair Access

Pros

• Tesla Repair Access: Erie provides connections to Tesla-certified repair facilities for quality service.
• New Car Replacement: Replaces totaled Teslas with a new model under qualifying policies.
• Top Claims Satisfaction: Tesla drivers give Erie high marks for responsive claims handling, especially in the East.

Cons

• Limited Geographic Reach: Erie’s Tesla insurance is only available in 12 states.
• Fewer Online Tools: While bundling savings are substantial, Erie lacks advanced quote customization.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes from Top Companies and Save

Auto Home Health Life Business Motorcycle Pet Medicare Rental

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Getting the Best Tesla Auto Insurance Discounts

When insuring a Tesla, it’s worth knowing which companies offer great deals for electric cars. The table indicates the top discounts, such as safe driving, bundling, and EV-specific discounts, that reduce your premium.

Insurance Company	Anti-Theft	Bundling	EV Discounts	Good Driver	Safe Driver
	10%	25%	14%	25%	18%
	25%	25%	17%	25%	18%
	15%	25%	15%	23%	15%
	10%	20%	12%	30%	20%
	35%	25%	16%	20%	20%
	5%	20%	11%	40%	12%
	5%	20%	11%	40%	12%
	25%	10%	8%	30%	10%
	15%	17%	10%	25%	20%
	15%	13%	9%	10%	17%

Extra savings come from driving a Tesla electric vehicle with advanced safety features, and bundling multiple policies helps you save with all ten companies.

Another big discount is the multi-vehicle discount, which is available when you have insured more than one vehicle with the same provider. Cheap providers like Erie, Geico, and Progressive provide multi-vehicle discounts that lower rates even more.

There are 17 car insurance discounts you shouldn’t miss that reduce premiums while making it easy to manage Tesla insurance coverage.

Auto Insurance Rates for Different Tesla Models

Insurance premiums on Teslas are different. The Model 3 is around $170 per month with less to repair, while the Model Y is around $190. Both are good choices for drivers who desire performance and affordability.

Teslas that are luxury cost more to insure. The Model S is around $285 per month, while the Model X is around $300. Owners would want to have the best auto insurance for luxury and exotic vehicles to cover these expensive models.

Future Teslas have variable rates. The Cybertruck should be around $210 a month, based on final specifications. Future Tesla Roadster, a sports car, might be priced roughly $290. Coverage will be highly important.

How to Find the Best Auto Insurance for Teslas

Finding the right Tesla auto insurance is key, as these EVs require specialized coverage due to their advanced technology and higher value. To help you make an informed decision, follow these five steps to secure the best coverage for your electric vehicle.

• Review Your Coverage Needs: Ensure your Tesla is fully covered with liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, considering its high worth and sophisticated features.
• Compare Automobile Insurance Providers: Take time to compare car insurance companies, as Tesla rates can differ. Compare quotes and seek EV-specialized coverage levels and discounts.
• Take Discounts and Deals: Ask about safe driving, multi-policy, and EV discounts—more than one carrier provides special discounts for Tesla owners.
• Assess Customer Service and Claims Experience: Select a firm that has excellent customer service and streamlined claims handling, ideally one knowledgeable about Tesla repair requirements and with certified shop collaborations.
• Review Deductibles and Coverage Limits: Equate your premium with a deductible that you can pay, and make sure coverage limits are high enough to cover your Tesla in the event of a significant claim.

Select Tesla insurance that meets your requirements and budget. Compare quotes, look for discounts, and select a provider with good claims support to safeguard your investment and enjoy peace of mind while driving.

Drivers find the best auto insurance for Teslas with Travelers, Progressive, and State Farm, which provide full coverage at competitive prices that start below $200 a month.

Progressive suits those who are fond of digital tools and straightforward access, whereas State Farm stands out with solid customer support and budget-friendly alternatives.

Numerous insurers also offer savings under safe driver plans, EV rewards, and discounts for bundling. Start saving on your Tesla auto insurance by entering your ZIP code and comparing quotes.